BONES OF HAND- METACARPAL
| A | Index metacarpal | |
| B | Ring metacarpal | |
| C | Thumb metacarpal | |
| D | Middle finger metacarpal |
| A | Index metacarpal | |
| B | Ring metacarpal | |
| C | Thumb metacarpal | |
| D | Middle finger metacarpal |
All the metacarpals in the hand have one epiphysis per bone which is in the head of the bone except the thumb, where it is in the base
Bennett’s fracture is fracture dislocation of base of — metacarpal:
| A |
4th |
|
| B |
3rd |
|
| C |
2nd |
|
| D |
1st |
D i.e. 1st
A 35 – year old male develops involvements of PIP, DIP and metacarpophalangeal joints with sparing of wrist and carpometacarpal joints. The probable diagnosis is:
| A |
Psoriatic arthopathy |
|
| B |
Osteo arthritis |
|
| C |
Rheumatoid arthritis |
|
| D |
Pseudo gout |
Answer is A (Psoriatic arthropathy):
Psoriatic arthritis involves PIP, DIP and metacarpophalangeal joints, and may or may not involve the wrist.
- Involvement of DIP makes rheumatoid arthritis unlikely. DIP is spared in rheumatoid arthritis.
- Involvement of metacarpophalangeal joints makes osteoarthritis unlikely. Metacarpophalangeal joints and carpometacarpal joint with the exception of base of thumb are spared in osteoarthritis.
| A | Rheumatoid arthritis | |
| B |
Pseudogout |
|
| C |
Psoriatic arthropathy |
|
| D |
Osteoarthritis |
Answer is D (Osteoarthritis) :
Sparing of wrist and metacarpophalangeal joint with involvement of base of thumb (i.e. carpometacarpal joint) is very characteristic of `osteoarthritis’.
Both DIP (Herbeden’s nodes) and PIP (Bouchard’s nodes) are involved in osteoarthritis.Q
DIP is the most common form of idiopathic O.A.
| A |
Osteoarthritis |
|
| B |
Psoriatic arthropathy |
|
| C |
Rheumatoid arthritis |
|
| D |
Pseudogout |
Answer is A (Osteoarthritis)
A patient has hyperphosphatemia with short metacarpals and associated cataract. The diagnosis is:
| A |
Pseudohypoparathyroidism |
|
| B |
Hypophophatasia |
|
| C |
Hyperparathyroidism |
|
| D |
Osteomalacia |
Answer is A (Pseudohypoparathyroidism):
The presence of hyperphosphatemia (Serum phosphate) along with characteristic brachydactyly suggests the diagnosis of pseudohypoparathyroidism.
Pseudohypoparathyroidism
- This is a hereditary disorder associated with symptoms and signs of hypoparathyroidism despite an elevated PTH level (pseudohypoparathyroidism)
- This is produced as a result of deficient end organ response to PTH.
| A | Klinefelter syndrome | |
| B |
Turner syndrome |
|
| C |
Cri du chat syndrome |
|
| D |
Noonan syndrome |
Answer is B (Turner’s Syndrome) :
Noonan syndrome presents with most features similar to Turner’s Syndrome. Webbing of neck, increased carrying angle, low hair line are present in both Noonan’s and Turner’s Syndrome but short fourth metacarpal is characteristic of Turner’s Syndrome only.
Term Noonan syndrome has been applied to males and females who present with phenotypic features of Turner’s Syndrome but have a normal Karyotype (46X, Y or 46 XX)
|
Turner’s Syndrome |
Noonan’s Syndrome |
|
• Defect in X chromosome |
• Autosomal dominant disorder |
|
• Karyotype is XO |
• Karyotype is normal (46 X, X or 46 X, Y) |
|
• Phenotypic females only Q (female sex only) |
• Phenotypic Males or females (seen in both sexes) |
|
Manifestations |
Manifestations |
|
• Short stature |
• Short stature |
|
• Webbed neck |
• Webbed neck |
|
• Low posterior hair line |
• Low posterior hair line |
|
• Characteristic facies – Hypertelorism – Epicanthus – Slanted palpebral fissures – Ptosis – Micrognathia – Ear abnormalities |
• Characteristic facies – Hypertelrism – Epicanthus – Slanted palpebral fissures – Ptosis – Micrognathia – Ear abnormalities |
|
• Cubitus valgus |
• Cubitus valgus |
|
• Borad chest with widely spaced nipples |
• Pectus carinatum / Pectus excavatum |
|
• Cardiac defect : – Most commonly coarctation of aorta and bicuspid aortic valve |
• Cardiac defect : – Most common cardiac defect is pulmonary valvular stenosis, Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, ASD |
|
• Sensorineural hearing loss |
• Sensorineural hearing loss |
|
• Short fourth metacarpal |
‑ |
|
• No mental retardation |
• Mental retardation present |
AIIMS 09
| A | Klinefelter syndrome | |
| B |
Turner syndrome |
|
| C |
Cri-du-chat syndrome |
|
| D |
Noonan syndrome |
Ans. Turner syndrome
Normal metacarpal index is:
| A |
Less than 5.4 |
|
| B |
5.4 to 7.9 |
|
| C |
8.4 to 10.4 |
|
| D |
More than 10.4 |
Ans. 5.4 to 7.9
1st carpometacarpal joint is‑
| A |
Pivot |
|
| B |
Hinge |
|
| C |
Ball and Socket |
|
| D |
Saddle |
Saddle
Arthritis involving DIP, PIP, 1st carpometacarpal with sparing of MCP and wrist joints is typical of ‑
| A |
Osteoarthritis |
|
| B |
Rheumatoid arthritis |
|
| C |
Ankylosing spondylitis |
|
| D |
Psoriatic arthritis |
Ans. is ‘a’ i.e., Osteoarthritis
1st Carpometacarpal joint Wrist- Osteoarthritis
Pt carpometacarpal joint is a type of ‑
| A |
Ellipsoid |
|
| B |
Saddle |
|
| C |
Condylar |
|
| D |
Ball and socket |
Ans. is ‘b’ i.e., Saddle
Short 4th metacarpal is a feature of
| A |
Hyperparathyroidism |
|
| B |
Hypoparathyroidism |
|
| C |
Pseudohypoparathyroidism |
|
| D |
Scleroderma |
Ans. is `c’ i.e., Pseudohypoparathyroidism
Shortening of the fourth/fifth metacarpals/metatarsals
- Shortening of the fourth/fifth metacarpals and less commonly metatarsals is seen in a variety of apparently disparate conditions.
Etiology
Common causes :
- idiopathic
- post-infective (e.g. osteomyelitis, yaws, tuberculosis dactylitis)
- pseudohypoparathyroidism/pseudopseudohypoparathyroidism
- post-traumatic (acute or chronic/healed and particularly those involving growth plate)
- Turner syndrome
Uncommon causes :
- basal cell nevus syndrome (Gorlin syndrome)
- hereditary multiple exostosis syndrome
- juvenile idiopathic arthritis
- sickle cell disease with secondary infarction
- homocystinuria
- Langer-Giedion syndrome
Isolated shortening of the 5th metacarpals has been recently described in a familial variant of type 1 diabetes mellitus .
Radiographic features
Plain radiograph:
- Hand x-rays readily identify the abnormality and can be assessed by drawing a line along the heads of the 4th and 5th metacarpals.
- If this line intersects the head of the 3rd metacarpal then shortening is deemed to be present.
Thus, shortened 4th metacarpal is the key to this finding. It is known as the metacarpal sign.

